Psychology Behind Lasting Behavior Change

Everyone has habits they want to change. Parents want their kids to make better choices. Employers want their teams to be more productive. People want to improve their own lives. The most common strategy is to use threats and warnings—scare people into making better choices. But research shows that fear rarely works the way we expect.

Why Fear-Based Warnings Fall Flat

Scare tactics seem logical. If people know the risks, they’ll make better choices. Health campaigns rely on graphic cigarette warnings. Parents tell their kids smoking will kill them. Bosses warn of consequences for missed deadlines.

Science shows that warnings have very limited impact on behavior. When animals feel threatened, they usually freeze or flee—not fight. Humans react the same way. Fear causes people to shut down, ignore the warning, or find ways to rationalize their behavior. Smokers see graphic cigarette labels and tell themselves, “My grandpa smoked and lived to 90. I’ll be fine.”

The same pattern shows up in financial behavior. People check their investment accounts more frequently when the stock market is rising. When the market drops, they avoid looking at their accounts. A study analyzing S&P 500 data found that during downturns, people logged in less often, choosing to ignore bad news. But when the financial crisis of 2008 hit, they scrambled to check their accounts—by then, it was too late to act.

This selective attention happens in other areas of life too. In an experiment, participants estimated their chances of experiencing negative events like hearing loss. When given expert opinions—one better, one worse—they adjusted their beliefs toward the better outcome. Even when bad news was more accurate, people chose to believe the rosier version.

This pattern held across all ages. Kids, teenagers, and elderly adults were the least likely to learn from bad news. But even adults in their 30s, 40s, and 50s took in positive information more easily than negative information.

3 Things that Actually Work

Instead of relying on fear, people respond better to social incentives, immediate rewards, and progress monitoring.

1. The Power of Social Influence

People care about what others think and do. A British tax study proved this. When tax officials sent out late payment notices, compliance didn’t improve much. But when they added a single sentence—“9 out of 10 people pay their taxes on time”—compliance increased by 15%, bringing in an estimated £5.6 billion in revenue.

The same principle worked in hospitals. A study installed cameras to track how often medical staff sanitized their hands before entering a patient’s room. Even though doctors and nurses knew the cameras were there, only 10% followed proper handwashing procedures. Then, researchers introduced an electronic board that displayed handwashing compliance rates in real time. Every time a staff member sanitized their hands, the number on the screen went up. Almost immediately, compliance jumped to 90%. Seeing their colleagues’ behavior—and wanting to match or exceed it—made all the difference.

This effect isn’t limited to workplaces. Many German towns use speed radar displays at their entrances. Instead of issuing tickets, the screens show a driver’s speed, followed by a smiley face for safe speeds or a gentle request to slow down if they are going too fast. There’s no police enforcement—just immediate, positive feedback. People naturally want to comply when they receive encouragement rather than threats. The same principle applies to handwashing in hospitals, where real-time feedback changed behavior without punishment.

2. Why Instant Gratification Can Be a Force for Good

People are more likely to change when they receive an immediate benefit. Studies show that smokers are more likely to quit and people are more likely to exercise when they receive immediate incentives.

A real-world example of this principle appeared on an energy bill. Tali Sharot received a statement comparing her electricity usage to that of her neighbors. In gray, the bill showed the average usage in the neighborhood. In blue, it showed the household’s usage. In green, it showed the most energy-efficient home. The bill also included a smiley face for being slightly better than average.

The reaction was immediate. The homeowners felt good about doing slightly better than their neighbors. More importantly, they noticed an opportunity: if they reduced their energy use even more, they could reach the green bar and earn two smiley faces next time. That tiny reward was enough motivation to influence behavior.

3. Seeing Visible Progress Sparks Lasting Change

People stay motivated when they can see how far they’ve come. Instead of focusing on what’s wrong, highlighting progress makes a bigger impact.

This concept applies to smoking prevention. A parent who tells their child, “Smoking will ruin your lungs,” is using fear. But a parent who says, “If you quit smoking, you’ll get better at sports,” is framing the change as progress. The brain is wired to focus on improvement over decline.

A brain scan study backs this up. When people hear good news about the future, their brain efficiently processes the information. When they hear bad news, the brain doesn’t register it as strongly. This is why people respond better to messages that highlight progress rather than loss.

Why Feeling in Charge Makes Change Stick

People are more likely to stick with change when they feel like they’re in charge. The energy bill example worked because it gave people control over their choices. It showed them exactly how their actions influenced their energy use over time.

A similar effect happened in the hospital handwashing study. Staff didn’t just see numbers on a screen—they saw their shift’s performance and their own personal contribution to the team’s success. This sense of control motivated them to keep improving.

Forget Fear—This Is How Real Change Happens

Fear leads to avoidance. Encouragement leads to action. People naturally seek progress and respond best when they feel like they have control over their choices.

The most effective strategies use social incentives, immediate rewards, and progress monitoring:

• Show what others are doing. People want to follow social norms.

• Offer rewards in the moment. Even small incentives help build long-term habits.

• Highlight progress instead of decline. People are more motivated by how far they’ve come than by fear of what they might lose.

Instead of working against human nature, these strategies work with it—helping people create real, lasting change.

Full credits to Tali Sharot for the insight.

Top Tweets of the day

1/

I was always confused to people who used to post links but had no posts or very few posts on extremely unrelated niches.

Turns out, I was the dumb one. SEOs do this for a reason, i.e, creating profiles on a totally unrelated site for a backlink. For example, a marketing blog having a profile on a site for programmers like Dev.to!

2/

This method helps you discover keywords that a lower-DR site in your niche is already ranking for—eliminating guesswork.

Simply create better content and outrank them.

3/

So many millionaires, multi-millionaires, and billionaires can be attributed to TikTok Algorithm.

Rabbit Holes

1. Uhcut: My o3-mini AI Agent for Video Editing (Prompt to Chain to AI Agent) by IndyDevDan

2. De-scamming scammers and finding big wins by Edward Sturm

3. Efficiency Is An Excuse To Not Do The Actual Work by Trevor Mckendrick

What’d ya think of today’s newsletter? Hit ‘reply’ and let me know.

Do me a favor and share it in your company's Slack #marketing channel.

First time? Subscribe.

Follow me on X.

More Startup Spells 🪄

1. Keyword Research for UGC Sites like Quora and Reddit (LINK)

2. Psychological Biases Mr.Beast uses (LINK)

3. Reverse-Engineering Distribution (via Open Analytics) (LINK)

4. Hijack Attention (using Pattern Interrupt) (LINK)