Natasha Willis’ Instagram DM Strategy: $725K in 90 Days with Rule of Three System

Turning organic social media engagement into predictable revenue is a challenge for most businesses.

This case study by Natasha Willis of School of Bots, breaks down the exact "Social Funnel Conversion System" that transformed a brand's Instagram content into a highly profitable machine.

The strategy took the client from a mere 10% to an astonishing 70% revenue attribution from their organic efforts alone.

This is the same framework Willis and her team have used to generate over $80M for an elite client list that includes Nike, ClickFunnels, Russell Brunson, Amy Porterfield, Mindvalley, Codie Sanchez, Her First 100K, Your Rich BFF, Jenna Kutcher, Dean Graziosi, SoFi, and Matthew Hussey.

They've built a system that turns passive followers into paying customers using 24x7 automation.

The 'Rule of Three' Posting System: Train, Deliver, Convert

This system revolves around a three-post cycle that conditions followers to expect value—and take action.

Best for: Brands posting at least 4x per week. The featured client was posting 5x a day, so this system integrated easily into their schedule.

Posts 1 & 2: Give Pure Value—No Strings Attached

• Purpose: Build trust, credibility, and attention.

• Content types: Teaching, entertaining, inspiring, motivating.

• No CTA, no funnels, no DM prompts.

• Establishes the account as a consistent source of value without the pressure to buy.

Post 3: Insert a Direct, Strategic CTA

• Purpose: Capture interest and start conversations.

• Tactics: Ask followers to comment a specific word to receive a free resource.

• Examples:

  • "Comment GROW for my free challenge."

  • "Comment SYSTEM to apply to work with me."

• Why it works:

  • Low-friction engagement—no links or landing pages.

  • Boosts algorithm reach.

  • Signals to followers (and non-followers) that the account offers tangible value.

The 3-Point DM Script That Instantly Separated Hot Leads From Cold Followers

Getting the comment is only the first step. The real conversion power is unlocked in the DMs through a sophisticated, automated qualification process that feels personal and conversational, not like an interrogation.

Step 1: Conversational Qualification

• Goal: Learn whether they’re a hot lead or need nurturing.

• The 3 key questions:

  1. Current income level

  2. Intent to buy a solution

  3. Timeline for starting

• Feels human and helpful—not like an interrogation.

Step 2: Smart Routing Based on Lead Quality

• High-Intent Leads:

  • Fast-tracked to a live sales call.

  • Closed quickly while interest is high.

• Nurture-Stage Leads:

  • Enter automated sequences across DMs, SMS, and email.

  • Messages are tailored to the specific topic they engaged with.

    • Example: Someone who comments on a money mindset post gets follow-ups about that exact topic.

  • Hyper-personalized nurture = higher conversions.

The foundation of this strategy is a simple, repeatable content pattern designed to build trust and condition the audience to take action.

The Final Tally: $725K in Revenue, 136K New Followers, and a Compounding Business Asset

The results from implementing this system over a 90-day period were not just impressive—they were transformative, creating a predictable and scalable revenue engine.

• The 90-Day Performance Metrics:

  • Revenue: $725,000 generated in just under 90 days.

  • Lead Generation: 8,600 new emails and 5,700 new phone numbers captured.

  • Audience Growth: An explosion in follower count.

    • Month 1: 16,000 new followers

    • Month 2: 30,000 new followers

    • Month 3: 90,000 new followers

• The Compounding Asset Effect

  • Unlike paid ads that vanish when you stop paying, this organic content becomes a long-term, lead-generating asset. Instagram continues to circulate valuable posts long after they are published.

  • Proof of Longevity: Natasha Willis says that her client, Her First 100K, has a single post that is over two years old and still consistently generates new leads and sales every single month, proving the system's lasting power.

This system works for the following reasons:

• Consistency: Followers know to expect value and action.

• Trust-building: Two-thirds of content is purely helpful.

• Low-friction opt-ins: No links, just comments.

• Qualification: You know who’s serious within minutes.

• Personalized nurturing: Relevance boosts conversion.

• Longevity: Content becomes an asset that keeps paying off.

Most creators chase virality. This one built a vending machine that spits out revenue every time someone comments “GROW.”

Top Tweets of the day

1/

The new way to hack social feeds is to master these AI Video Tools and create videos for your niche. This blew my mind away. My mom watches worse AI-generated videos than this.

2/

This tip by a legendary programmer who invented TDD (which is perfect for AI programming) sums up how AI is in the hands of experts. Embrace it and use it to 1000x yourself.

There is a new generation of programmers that are using multiple AI Agents from different companies to collaborate with each other to get to consensus faster.

This is how people in actually companies work. They collaborate with each other. This technique spots nasty implementations faster since AI can do human work 10x faster.

Currently, it has been tried for coding but it'll soon be tried for every other industry. For example, a Copywriter agent talks to a Psychology Agent which then talks to Facebook Ads Agent to make an AI ad for Facebook. This only works if you know what good output looks like.

Google's A2A framework is specifically made for this.

3/

Crazy insight. TIL Sundays are the worst days for addicts.

Rabbit Holes

1. The State of Consumer Tech in the Age of AI by a16z

2. Levered beta is all you need by TextQL

3. I grew to 1,000,000 followers in 14 months - AMA! by /r/InstagramMarketing

What’d ya think of today’s newsletter? Hit ‘reply’ and let me know.

Do me a favor and share it in your company's Slack #marketing channel.

First time? Subscribe.

Follow me on X.

More Startup Spells 🪄

1. How Ecommerce Brand Findlay Hats Made $28,000 Overnight From One Emotional Reddit Post (LINK)

2. Dwarkesh Patel's $2000 Thumbnail Competition (LINK)

3. How Daniel Vassallo Earned $200,000 with Unlimited Consultations (LINK)

4. 4 Generative AI SaaS Trends for 2024 (LINK)