Fitness Challenge Turns Nobody Into Million-Follower Instagram Creator

Chewy Thompson went from 500 Instagram followers to over 122,000 in just 8 days.

The growth was exponential in the initial days:

• Day 1: 520 followers

• Day 2: 526 followers

• Day 3: 535 followers

• Day 4: 644 followers

• Day 5: 1,938 followers

• Day 6: 16,000 followers

• Day 7: 50,000 followers

• Day 8: 88,000 followers

This led to his current milestone: 1 million+ followers in 260 Days

The explosion happened between days 4-7, when follower count jumped from hundreds to tens of thousands.This spike happened because Chewy documented his authentic struggle throughout the journey, showing the real person behind the challenge.

Simple Challenge Rules Create Perfect Engagement Loop

Chewy set up clear, easy-to-understand rules:

• For every 1 follower total, he walks 1 inch each day

• For every 1,000 followers total, he does 1 pushup each day

This formula creates perfect tension. As followers increase, the challenge gets harder. The audience knows exactly what impact their follow has on his daily routine.

Pain Sells More Than Perfection

Chewy struggled with even a single pushup at the start of his challenge. This authentic difficulty resonated with viewers more than polished content would have.

The pattern matches what works for top creators. Mr. Beast's highest-retention videos feature him suffering (like staying in a box underground). His other viral hits include counting to 100,000 or saying "Pewdiepie" or "Logan Paul" 100,000 times - all endurance challenges that showcase struggle.

Viewers connect with real difficulty because it shows human vulnerability. Perfection creates distance; struggle creates connection.

Follower-Based Difficulty Creates Self-Perpetuating Growth

The genius of Chewy's challenge lies in its self-reinforcing nature:

1. More followers = harder challenge

2. Harder challenge = more compelling content

3. More compelling content = more followers

This loop turns passive viewers into active participants. Every new follower adds to the challenge, making people feel directly responsible for Chewy's journey.

At his current trajectory, Chewy faces doing 1,000 pushups and walking 15 miles daily by the end of his challenge - a dramatic transformation from where he started.

The fitness journey seems impressive, but a body doing 15-mile walks and hundreds of pushups daily would show more dramatic physical changes than what we're seeing, revealing how gullible his audience truly is. Most people don't even know how much toll 15 miles really takes on the legs while running (let alone walking) but its still a good marketing/storytelling trick.

Deletion Countdown Forces Urgency

At the end of each video, Chewy adds dramatic stakes: "I'm deleting this channel in 365 days unless I reach 1 million followers."

This countdown serves multiple purposes:

• Creates a clear deadline for action

• Adds real consequences to failure

• Gives viewers a reason to share content

• Makes following feel like helping

The 365-day timeframe provides both urgency and enough runway for growth. Viewers understand exactly what success looks like: 1 million followers before time runs out.

Celebrity Connection Expands Appeal Beyond Fitness

Chewy sets working out with John Cena as his ultimate goal. This smart move:

• Creates a concrete aspiration beyond just follower count

• Connects his challenge to a wider cultural figure

• Gives viewers an additional reason to help him succeed

• Shows he has dreams beyond just social media fame

This celebrity connection humanizes the challenge, making Chewy relatable despite his growing follower count. Everyone understands what it means to have a dream meeting with someone you admire.

The combination of these elements - authentic struggle, clear rules, self-reinforcing difficulty, real stakes, and relatable dreams - created the perfect conditions for viral growth. Chewy's journey demonstrates that with the right formula, explosive audience growth remains possible even in today's crowded social media landscape.

Top Tweets of the day

1/

Gold explanation of ChatGPT's memory feature.

2/

I sometimes do this, not always but LLMs are good at asking questions if you give it incomplete information.

Try this all the time until you get good at giving complete information.

3/

Most meme pages don't convert as it attracts low intent followers. But if you have product-page fit, you can convert them for very cheap.

Rabbit Holes

1. CTR Manipulation Course: #1 SEO Rankings by Using Click Through Rate Manipulation by William Jones

2. Prompt Engineering Whitepaper by Google

3. How We Work (Volume IV) by Jake Cooper

What’d ya think of today’s newsletter? Hit ‘reply’ and let me know.

Do me a favor and share it in your company's Slack #marketing channel.

First time? Subscribe.

Follow me on X.

More Startup Spells 🪄

1. AI Prompt Compression Slashes LLM Models Costs by 50% (LINK)

2. SaaS Showdown: All-in-One SaaS vs. Single-Feature SaaS (LINK)

3. Andrew Chen's 80/20 Principle To Find Product-Market Fit (PMF) (LINK)

4. The Genius of Dynamic Pricing in B2C Apps (LINK)