Semi-Hard Paywall Strategy: Snapchat, Spiral, & B2C Mobile Apps

The semi-hard paywall strategy sounds counterintuitive. Lock users out after they've created content, then deny access to their own work.

Apps using it see 2-3x MRR with the same traffic.

Spiral implements it perfectly. Rohan Dave's formula explains why it works. Snapchat weaponized it to trap millions.

The secret is not locking people out. The secret is how you let them back in.

How Spiral turns free trials into hostage situations

Spiral's onboarding gives you full access upfront. Write blog posts. Polish your ideas. Feel productive.

Day 7 hits. The paywall appears. You can't access what you created.

This triggers loss aversion. Losing something feels twice as painful as gaining something feels good. Your blog posts are not features anymore. They are your property being held hostage.

The objection is not "Is this worth $25?" The objection becomes "Can I afford to lose what I already made?"

Spiral's trial timeline shows the setup:

• Day 1: unlock full features

• Day 5: reminder notification

• Day 7: charge date with cancel option

By day 7, using the app is a habit. Losing access disrupts your workflow. Paying $25 becomes cheaper than finding alternatives.

Rohan Dave's consumer app formula that hasn't failed

Rohan Dave shared the formula that consistently delivers 2-3x MRR:

• Engineer emotional onboarding with cinematic or time-sink Q&A

• Semi-hard paywall at 3-7 days

• Lock users out of content they created unless they pay

• If they do not pay at onboarding, offer 100% free premium without disclosing duration

• Weekly or annual plans only

The close button gamble makes this work. When the paywall appears, a close button shows up for 10-15 seconds. If users close it fast, the app gifts them free premium. It feels like beating the system.

This filters users brilliantly. People who close immediately were not going to pay anyway. Users who hesitate past 15 seconds lose the close button. Now paying feels like their choice, not forced.

Result: paid users increase from 10% to 20% with lower churn. Same traffic, 2-3x MRR.

Snapchat's memory hostage psychology at scale

Snapchat's storage paywall operates on the same principle but amplified.

They show you numbers: "8,227 memories since 2014" and "29.8GB of 5GB used." Then threaten to backup new memories for only 12 months.

The implication is clear: pay or lose years of photos.

Notice "Join 48 friends" on the $4.99 plan. Social proof plus loss aversion. Your friends paid to keep their memories. Are yours worth less?

"Cancel anytime in the App Store" appears at the bottom, making commitment feel reversible even though most users never cancel.

Snapchat isn't selling storage. They're selling protection from regret.

Some users feel manipulated when you lock them out of their data. But apps using this see paid users double because the users who stay chose to pay. The users who leave were never going to convert anyway.

The formula is simple: emotional onboarding, full access upfront, then lock them out of what they created with a 10-15 second escape window. Weekly or annual only.

You are not selling features. You are selling the ability to keep what users already built.

Top Tweets of the day

1/

Finding under-identified niche is a great arbitrage opportunity. These always exist in the market but you have to have a good eye to spot them and execute fast because they go out as fast as they appear.

In all aspects of life, speed to action is underrated.

2/

Love this.

3/

Less wrong is real insightful.

Rabbit Holes

1. Scriptwriting Mastermind: How We Use Storytelling to Outperform 80% of Meta Ads

2. The “Peaks” Model: How To Boost Customer Lifetime Value & Unlock Hidden Profits

3. Travis Scott’s Fortnite performance attracted 28 MILLION people! How else did he CASH-IN?

What’d ya think of today’s newsletter? Hit ‘reply’ and let me know.

Do me a favor and share it in your company's Slack #marketing channel.

First time? Subscribe.

Follow me on X.

More Startup Spells 🪄

1. TrustMRR Marketing: Get SEO Backlinks by Sharing Revenue (LINK)

2. Disenshittification of Google (LINK)

3. IndiePage and Shipfast as a Marketing Channel (LINK)

4. Hidden Psychology Behind Redreach’s Pricing: Anchoring Effect (LINK)

5. How Plausible Analytics Grew to $300k+ MRR on the Back of Hacker News (LINK)