"First to Social" Playbook: How Early Adopters Steal the Spotlight on New Platforms

Being "first to social" means moving into new platforms (or brand-new features) before they become saturated. When demand outstrips early content supply, algorithms lean on whoever's posting—handing early adopters outsized distribution.

If the platform explodes, they ride the wave. If it stalls, they risk wasted effort.

The Physics of Going First: 3 Hidden Forces That Supercharge New-Platform Reach

The early-adopter edge is not luck.

First, the technology adoption lifecycle concentrates attention among Innovators and Early Adopters before the crowd arrives, creating path-dependent defaults.

Second, new platforms face a cold-start and content scarcity problem—feeds must be filled, so the bar to earn test distribution is lower.

Third, network effects reward the earliest high-engagement accounts as "default follows" across discovery and "who to follow" modules, compounding reach.

On mature platforms, this same dynamic applies to brand-new features (e.g., Instagram Reels, YouTube Shorts, LinkedIn Newsletters) that are temporarily over-boosted to seed adoption.

Cold-Start Secrets: How Algorithms Treat Early Creators on New Platforms

Recommendation systems emphasize recall over precision in greenfield periods. That means more creators get initial test impressions, and strong signals (watch time, saves, reshares) escalate faster.

Early adopters who quickly discover the "house style" of a platform—six-second punchlines on Vine, sound-driven cuts on TikTok, conversational cadence on Clubhouse—become blueprints others emulate.

Handle real estate matters too: exact-match names (@rock) become searchable primitives that the platform later bakes into discovery.

The Hall of Early Fame (Case Studies): The Early-Adopter Playbook in Action

These are short-lived discovery boosts created by new features, lenient defaults, or immature spam checks.

Use them natively and ethically—then rotate once the window closes.

Substack's Newsletter Wave - Lenny Rachitsky's MasterPlan with Lenny's Newsletter

When paid newsletters were nascent, Lenny's Newsletter (2019) staked out long-form product and growth content early, quickly becoming the category default.

Lenny quickly became a 7-figure ARR Substack publication and grew as fast as Substack did.

Instagram's Influencer Era - Kim Kardashian's Playbook

In Instagram's 2012–2014 ramp, Kim Kardashian leaned into the platform before Hollywood professionalised social content, translating early reach into a diversified DTC empire.

Getting serious during the "push period" cemented her as a default follow for millions.

TikTok's Rocket - Charli D'Amelio rise to 100M followers

Charli D'Amelio began posting mid-2019 and became the first TikTok creator to hit 100 million followers by November 2020—about 18 months—by chaining trending sounds, simple cuts, and frequent posting to compound reach.

This tactic, known as trend stacking and sound hijacking, showcases how early recommendation dynamics compress time to scale.

Vine's 6-second explosion - Logan Paul, King Bach, Lele Pons

Vine (2013) minted a new class of star. Early Viners like King Bach (~16M), Lele Pons (10M+), and Logan Paul (~9M) used revine rings and collab houses to co-create and re-vine each other's clips, concentrating exposure across overlapping audiences before the feed matured.

When Vine shut down, those who had already ported to YouTube/Instagram (like Logan Paul) retained momentum; others vanished.

Duolingo's mascot masterclass on TikTok

While brands hesitated, Duolingo's TikTok leaned into native humor, turning a mascot into a character.

Case studies (e.g., PRWeek's breakdown) show how posting into the push window with a platform-native voice created a durable, high-reach brand channel.

Feature arbitrage inside mature platforms - Gymshark & LinkedIn

Gymshark was early to Instagram fitness influencer marketing (2013–2015), converting first-mover leverage into a global DTC brand.

On LinkedIn, early adopters of native video and newsletters (2023) rode an algorithmic push window to outsized B2B reach; consistently packaging expertise into serial formats turned reach into lead flow.

YouTube's format arbitrage - Casey Neistat

Even on a mature platform, being first-to-format pays. Casey Neistat launched a cinematic daily vlog in March 2015.

By treating titles and thumbnails as packaging and delivering fast, satisfying openings—a tactic known as CTR/retention loops—he boosted click-through and session time. This alignment with YouTube's satisfaction signals drove rapid growth, jumping from ~500k to 5M+ subs in under two years.

The Podcast Head Start - Tim Ferriss' Early Claim on Business Podcasts

Tim Ferriss's show launched in 2014 and became the first business interview podcast to cross 100 million downloads by 2016.

Layering an early blog + early podcast + email capture replicated the first-to-feature dynamic within audio.

The VC Math of New Platforms: A Few 100× Wins, Many Zeros

First-to-social is a high-variance bet: a few 100× outcomes subsidise many small wins or misses. The upside is uncapped organic reach, early category ownership, and leverage with platforms and partners; the downside, however, has massive risks.

• Platform failure or shutdown. Vine's shutdown erased top-of-feed distribution overnight. Creators who had already built on YouTube/Instagram migrated; single-platform stars lost most of their reach.

• Regulatory shocks. India's June 29, 2020, TikTok ban (coverage) vaporised the country's largest creator ecosystem. Many rebuilt on Reels/Shorts, but ceilings were lower than their TikTok peaks.

• Algorithm/policy swings. Tactics decay as platforms tighten rules—link throttling, pod detection, keyword bans, or de-emphasised formats. Expect volatility; today's booster can become tomorrow's drag.

• Monetisation lag & non-portability. Early stages often lack payouts, and audience may not follow across apps. Without owned channels (email/site) or multi-homing content, gains stay fragile and hard to monetise.

Practical mitigation: Multi-home your best formats (Reels ↔ Shorts; Threads ↔ X/Bluesky), capture emails early, and treat loopholes as temporary accelerants, not foundations.

As Andrew Chen's "Law of Shitty Clickthroughs" predicts, every channel decays—so capture upside early and keep moving.

TL;DR "First to social" is attention arbitrage: step in when audience demand overwhelms early content supply and when platforms over-boost new surfaces. That window closes—sometimes gradually (algorithm shifts), sometimes instantly (shutdowns, bans).

The durable winners—Lenny Rachitsky on Substack, Charli D'Amelio on TikTok, Duolingo's brand voice on TikTok, Casey Neistat's daily vlog, Gymshark's Instagram arbitrage—spotted the opening, shipped natively, collaborated relentlessly, and then diversified.

Treat each new platform like a portfolio bet: jump fast, learn faster, and build escape hatches. If the platform explodes, so does the creator who got there first.

Top Tweets of the day

1/

China is clever in doing that. The smart ones will find a way to bypass around it and the not-so-smart ones won't play for as long.

Look at the actions of billionaires and countries and you'll realize they don't allow their children to do what they preach in public.

China doesn't use the brain rot algorithm of TikTok. Similarly, Zucks doesn't allow his kids to be on socials.

2/

Thoughts become actions.

The elite athletes hire performance coaches that only say a variation of this thing: I believe in you. You can do it.

3/

This is the next opportunity. In a few years, when this becomes mainstream, many of these girls will be millionaires before they turn 22.

Rabbit Holes

1. 20,000 Likes for $300?? How I Used AI To Turbocharge My Facebook Page by AI In Real Life

2. Scaling from $0 MRR to $2000 in 3 Days: DoYouMail's Remarkable Journey by Tommy Clark

3. Field notes from publishing 150+ content assets per week by Fresent

What'd ya think of today's newsletter? Hit 'reply' and let me know.

Do me a favor and share it in your company's Slack #marketing channel.

First time? Subscribe.

Follow me on X.

More Startup Spells 🪄

1. X Long Form for SEO (LINK)

2. How Pintura Dominates Developer Searches (LINK)

3. TikTok SEO: Rank in TikTok Search with Exact Keywords, Series Content & Spark Ads (LINK)

4. The Viral Genius behind Ice Cream TikTok (LINK)

5. Greg Isenberg's IdeaBrowser: Killer Lead Magnet for Wantrepreneurs of The Startup Ideas Podcast (LINK)