- Startup Spells 🪄
- Posts
- Copy AI's Demand Generation SEO: 1M+ Clicks in 5 Months
Copy AI's Demand Generation SEO: 1M+ Clicks in 5 Months
PLUS: Directories Still Have Massive Potential
Startup Spells 🪄
November 16, 2025
Copy AI's Demand Generation SEO: 1M+ Clicks in 5 Months
Copy AI's SEO transformed an early-stage startup into a dominant force in search rankings. Within 5 months, Copy AI generated over a million clicks, increased impressions by 3x, and secured their position as the top-ranking AI copywriting tool.
January 2020. Copy AI launches their AI writing platform. They're one of the first movers in AI copywriting right after GPT-3.5 launched.
By 2022, they recognize an opportunity. Search demand for AI writing tools is about to explode.
But here's the thing: there's barely any search volume data yet. Most companies would wait. Copy AI didn't.
They partnered with uSERP, an SEO agency led by Jeremy Moser, to capitalize on the wave before competitors even noticed it was forming.
That was a phenomenal move as Copy AI now receives over 150,000 monthly visitors to just one cluster of high-intent content.
The First Mover Advantage in Demand Generation SEO
Copy AI's success started with recognizing a trend before the data proved it existed. This approach is known as demand generation SEO.
Instead of waiting for keyword research tools to show search volume, you identify emerging needs based on user behavior and market signals.
When Jeremy's team began working with Copy AI in early 2022, traditional keyword research tools showed minimal search volume for terms like "sentence rewriter" or "ai instagram caption generator."
But Copy AI had something better than keyword data. They had user behavior.
Their platform already hosted thousands of users creating content with specific tools. They knew exactly what people needed, even if those people weren't searching for it yet.
This insight drove their entire strategy. Instead of waiting for search volume to materialize, they built landing pages for every use case their tool supported:
Sentence rewriters
AI Caption generators
Meta description tools
Dozens of other AI writing applications
Copy AI Tools
Each page was product-led. Click a button, use the tool immediately. No friction.
Copy AI - Free Instagram Caption Generator Tool
The gamble paid off. Within months, search volume for AI writing tools exploded. Copy AI was already ranking first for most of them.
They were really good at getting that first mover's advantage before a lot of other tools cropped up and before some of that search volume was really even present.
When you rank in top positions early, you naturally attract links from journalists writing about the trend. Those links push rankings higher, which attracts more links. The rich get richer.
Content Intent Fit: Making Pages Worth Ranking
Here's where most companies fail with SEO. They build product pages and expect them to rank.
Jeremy's approach was different. Before building a single link, his team analyzed whether Copy AI's pages actually fit what Google wanted to show.
"If we're spending time building links to these pages, they need to actually rank. You have to analyze what Google is currently displaying and whether you can reasonably rank something that's product-led."
Early analysis revealed mixed search intent. Some queries pulled up blog content and listicles. Others showed product pages and tools.
Copy AI needed to bridge both intents.
They started adding collapsible FAQs to product pages. Short videos explaining how to use each tool. Clear CTAs that didn't overwhelm the content.
The pages evolved. When Jeremy noticed search results shifting toward more tools and fewer blog posts, they stripped out unnecessary content and focused on the product experience.
This wasn't set-it-and-forget-it optimization. They adapted as search intent changed, constantly testing what worked.
The principle was to not force a product page into a search result that wants educational content. And don't write a blog post when users want to jump straight into a tool.
The Link Building Strategy That Compounds Forever
Most link building fails because teams spread effort too thin.
Jeremy saw Copy AI had 30-40 different tool pages. Building links to all of them simultaneously would dilute impact.
Instead, they focused on momentum:
First, drive links to the hub page. The main tools directory that internally linked to every specific tool.
Let authority spread naturally through internal links. Watch which pages start moving up in rankings.
Then attack those winners with targeted link campaigns.
"Once we found out these are the ones moving from the internal linking standpoint, let's prioritize those from the external side. That's when you really start to see rankings climb."
This created a flywheel effect. Pages ranking in top positions naturally attracted more links from journalists writing about AI tools. Those links pushed rankings higher, which attracted more links.
For competitive terms like "sentence rewriter," content optimization only goes so far. Authority determines winners.
Copy AI built that authority systematically. High-quality links from relevant sources. Consistent campaigns targeting their best-performing pages.
The result was a moat competitors couldn't easily cross especially when combined with the first-mover advantage.
Here's a mistake most SEO teams make. They build links to their homepage or blog posts because those are easier to promote.
Then they wonder why their product pages don't rank.
Jeremy's insight? You need page-level authority for competitive searches, not just domain-level strength.
When Copy AI's competitors all have similar domain authority, the difference comes down to which specific pages have the strongest backlink profiles.
This means getting creative. Product pages are harder to promote because they're inherently commercial. But that's exactly why building links to them creates a competitive advantage.
Find angles that make your product pages worth linking to:
Add unique data or research
Include expert insights and quotes
Publish case studies that demonstrate results
Create genuinely useful resources beyond just the product
Make the page valuable beyond just the product itself.
Jeremy's team published "The State of Backlinks" report for their own agency. It ranks for zero keywords. But it generates hundreds of links annually from quality sources.
The reason it ranks because they surveyed industry experts, compiled raw data, and gave those experts early access. When the report launched, those experts promoted it. Journalists cited it. Links accumulated naturally.
Five Title Optimizations That Doubled Click-Through Rates
Rankings matter. But clicks matter more.
Jeremy noticed Copy AI could rank 3rd or 4th for valuable terms but still win traffic by optimizing titles for clicks.
Here's what worked:
Stop writing the same headline as everyone else. If 10 results all say "10 Best AI Writing Tools," yours needs to stand out.
Call out your specific audience. Instead of "AI Writing Tools," try "AI Writing Tools for Content Marketers."
Address the biggest objection upfront in your title. Free, fast, no credit card required. Whatever makes people hesitate, handle it upfront.
Use specificity over vagueness. Numbers, timeframes, and concrete outcomes perform better than generic promises.
Test angles, not just keywords. Your keyword is your topic. Your angle is what makes someone click your result instead of the nine others.
Copy AI experimented constantly with title variations. Small changes produced massive CTR improvements, which signaled to Google that their pages deserved higher rankings.
The CTR improvements became a leading indicator of ranking success. When click-through rates jumped, rankings followed within weeks.
The AI Search Prediction Worth Considering
Jeremy made a prediction about AI's impact on SEO that's worth considering.
"In terms of AI's impact on SEO, I think it'll be a little more understated than most people expect. Middle and bottom of the funnel B2B content is going to be way less impacted."
His reasoning is that people don't trust AI overviews for high-stakes decisions.
Nobody asks ChatGPT what $50,000 software to buy for their business and trusts the first answer. They research. They read reviews. They compare options.
Top-of-funnel consumer queries will see massive disruption. But B2B software searches which are more bottom-of-funnel? Less so.
Copy AI bet on this insight. They focused on high-intent, product-led content that serves users ready to try the tool.
That content remains valuable regardless of how AI search evolves.
Copy AI's Playbook for Demand Generation SEO
Copy AI's success came from 5 core principles that apply to any competitive space:
Move early on emerging trends, even without keyword data. Trust user behavior over search volume metrics.
Build pages that match search intent, not just your preferred format. Adapt as Google's understanding evolves.
Focus link building on pages that matter, not pages that are easy. Page-level authority wins competitive searches.
Optimize titles for clicks, not just keywords. Standing out in search results drives rankings.
Create genuinely unique data that journalists and industry experts want to reference naturally.
The execution takes discipline. It’s easier to follow best practices than to do what competitors aren't willing to do. Like building authority to commercial pages or creating content before search volume exists.
But that's how Copy AI won. The keyword data eventually caught up, but by then, they were already in first place with a link profile competitors couldn't match. That's the real advantage: not just being first to see the trend, but being first to own it.
That's the real advantage. Not being first to see the trend. Being first to own it.
Credits to Jeremy Moser for the insight.
Top Tweets of the day
1/
Companies die in the middle. Either go cheap or expensive.
2/
Memes spread faster especially when they're really funny.
3/
Old marketing strategies often work with newer products. Human behavior is predictable.
Rabbit Holes
What’d ya think of today’s newsletter? Hit ‘reply’ and let me know.
Do me a favor and share it in your company's Slack #marketing channel.
First time? Subscribe.
Follow me on X.
Reply